If you use Zebras to measure the levels of an S-Log3 image then you should consider using a narrower Zebra range or window than the normal default 10% (+5% / -5%).
Zebras were originally conceived for use with Rec-709 and other normal gamma curves. With Rec-709 above middle grey each stop of exposure occupies around 16% of the recording range. So when using Zebras with a 10% or -5% to +5% window to measure a specific value, perhaps a white card or grey card on average you will be accurate to around +/- 1/3rd of a stop. On a grey card if you have set your zebras to 50% your zebras would start to appear at 45% and disappear at 55%, you will have an error of under half a stop at most. This is reasonable and when measuring something like skin tones which may cover a large range anyway works perfectly fine.
But when using Zebras to measure the levels of S-Log3 you need to use a much narrower range to achieve the same accuracy. Between middle grey and white each stop of the S-Log3 curve only occupies approx 8.5% of the recording range. So, if you use the default 10% zebra range your accuracy will at best be +/- 3/4 of stop. With the default -5% to +5% range if you set your zebras to 41% to measure the level of a grey card Zebras will appear at 36% , almost a stop under exposed and go all the way up to 46%, almost 3/4 of a stop over. With a zebra window 1.2 stops wide thats a lot of potential for incorrect exposure.
I would suggest that when using Zebras to measure S-Log3 you should reduce the range of the zebra window to -3% +3% to achieve a similar level of accuracy as you would have when measuring rec-709. If you are only using Zebras to determine the exposure of a white card or grey card you may want to go all the way down to -1% +1% if you want even better accuracy.
We provide the cinematography community with information, inspiration, and news.
SonyCine is here for the filmmakers and cinematographers who like to stay in the know, keep innovating, and connect with the world in meaningful ways. You bring your curiosity and ideas, and we'll provide the knowledge, inspiration, and state-of-the-art tech to help you bring your vision to life.